California Observer

California Plastic Law Faces Reporting Gaps Under SB 54

California Plastic Law Faces Reporting Gaps Under SB 54
Photo Credit: Unsplash.com

California’s plastic law faces reporting challenges after CalRecycle replaced its earlier 2.9 million-ton estimate with a 1.03 million-ton baseline for covered plastic packaging and food service ware. The November 2, 2026 update includes data from only about half of participating producers, leaving gaps in the information used to measure statewide reduction targets under Senate Bill 54.

Key Takeaways

  • California’s SB 54 requires a 25% statewide reduction in covered single-use plastic materials by 2032
  • CalRecycle reduced its estimated 2023 plastic packaging baseline from 2.9 million tons to approximately 1.03 million tons
  • The revised baseline includes data from 2,127 producers, representing about half of participating producers
  • The estimated number of covered plastic components increased from 171.4 billion to 222 billion
  • CalRecycle plans to update the baseline in November 2027 using corrected and more complete producer data

California’s SB 54 Sets Plastic Packaging Reduction Requirements

California’s Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, established through Senate Bill 54 in 2022, requires statewide reductions in covered single-use plastic packaging and plastic food service ware.

The legislation establishes phased source-reduction targets of 10% by January 1, 2027, 20% by January 1, 2030, and 25% by January 1, 2032. Progress is measured against the amount of covered plastic material sold, offered for sale or distributed in California during 2023.

The requirements form part of California’s broader approach to plastic waste management. SB 54 operates separately from California’s updated plastic bag rules, which restrict carryout bags provided at retail checkout.

Under SB 54, the producer responsibility organization, Circular Action Alliance, coordinates implementation of the statewide reduction requirements through a plan subject to CalRecycle approval. Participating producers contribute through reporting, packaging changes and other measures included in the program.

The statewide targets are collective rather than identical percentage requirements imposed on every individual producer. CalRecycle evaluates progress using both the weight of covered plastic materials and the number of plastic components distributed in California.

Accurate producer reporting is necessary to establish these measurements. Incomplete submissions can affect the baseline used to assess whether statewide reduction requirements are being met.

CalRecycle Identifies Incomplete Producer Reporting

CalRecycle’s November 2026 baseline update identified gaps in the information submitted by companies participating in California’s plastic packaging program.

The updated report incorporates data from 2,127 producers, representing approximately 50% of participating producers. Some companies were not represented in the figures, while other submissions contained incomplete or inaccurate information.

The reporting process requires producers to account for covered plastic materials associated with their California operations. These figures include the total weight of plastic covered material and the number of plastic components sold, offered for sale or distributed within the state.

Incomplete submissions prevent regulators from establishing a comprehensive account of the plastic materials covered by the law. Incorrect quantities can also affect calculations used to determine statewide source-reduction requirements.

CalRecycle is working with producers and Circular Action Alliance to improve reporting accuracy. The agency has identified additional reporting guidance and corrections as part of its approach to addressing the deficiencies.

The November update uses producer-reported information rather than the modeling approach used to establish the original baseline in December 2024. As a result, the difference between the two estimates should not be interpreted as evidence that California’s actual plastic consumption declined by the same amount.

The current figure reflects the available data, not necessarily the complete amount of covered plastic material distributed throughout the state in 2023.

Revised Plastic Packaging Baseline Changes Reduction Calculations

The updated packaging baseline changes the estimated amount of plastic associated with California’s reduction targets.

CalRecycle originally estimated that approximately 2.9 million tons of covered plastic material entered California’s market in 2023. Its November 2026 update reduced that figure to approximately 1.03 million tons.

Applying the law’s 25% reduction percentage to those two estimates produces substantially different results:

  • Original baseline: 2.9 million tons, equivalent to a 725,000-ton reduction at 25%
  • Revised baseline: 1.03 million tons, equivalent to a 257,500-ton reduction at 25%
  • Difference: Approximately 467,500 tons between the two calculated reductions

These figures illustrate the effect of changing the estimated starting weight. They do not represent fixed tonnage obligations imposed on every producer, because SB 54 also measures plastic components and allows multiple source-reduction approaches under the statewide program.

The updated report estimates 222 billion plastic components were distributed in 2023, compared with the earlier estimate of 171.4 billion. The increase in component count occurred alongside the lower estimated weight.

Both measurements are relevant to the state’s assessment of packaging reduction. A decrease in estimated tonnage does not necessarily mean a corresponding decrease in the number of plastic items covered by the legislation.

The revised baseline remains subject to correction as CalRecycle obtains additional producer information. Future adjustments could change the calculated quantities associated with the 2027, 2030 and 2032 reduction targets without changing the statutory percentages.

Producers Face Reporting Responsibilities and Compliance Risks

Companies covered by SB 54 must meet applicable reporting requirements and participate in the producer responsibility framework. Their submissions allow CalRecycle to assess the amount of covered plastic material distributed in California and monitor progress toward statewide targets.

Producers are required to provide accurate information about plastic packaging weight and component quantities. They must also address errors identified in their submissions under the applicable reporting regulations.

Alongside these obligations, companies can adopt ways to reduce packaging waste, including packaging redesigns, refill systems and material substitutions. These measures can contribute to source-reduction efforts when they meet the program’s requirements.

Reporting compliance remains a separate responsibility. A company that changes its packaging practices must still submit the information required under the law.

CalRecycle has emphasized working with producers to improve the completeness and accuracy of submitted data. This includes providing guidance, reviewing corrections and coordinating with Circular Action Alliance.

However, producers that continue to fail to submit required information or provide inaccurate reports could face enforcement action and potential penalties under the regulatory framework.

Reporting deficiencies should not automatically be treated as violations of the 2032 reduction target. The current concerns involve the completeness of the information used to establish and monitor statewide requirements.

For participating businesses, accurate records and timely corrections are essential to meeting reporting obligations and supporting the state’s implementation of SB 54.

CalRecycle Plans Another Baseline Update in November 2027

CalRecycle plans to publish another update to the 2023 source-reduction baseline in November 2027. The revision is expected to incorporate additional submissions and corrections from producers whose information was missing or inaccurate in the November 2026 report.

The agency intends to complete that update before reviewing compliance with the law’s source-reduction requirements through the first annual reporting process scheduled for July 2028.

The planned correction does not change the existing reduction deadlines. The statewide program remains subject to the 10% target for 2027, followed by 20% in 2030 and 25% in 2032.

The next baseline update will provide a more complete measure of the covered plastic materials distributed in California during 2023. Its accuracy will depend on producer participation, the quality of submitted records and the resolution of identified reporting deficiencies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is California’s Senate Bill 54?

Senate Bill 54 establishes an extended producer responsibility program for covered single-use packaging and plastic food service ware in California. It requires statewide source reductions of 25% for covered plastic materials by 2032.

Why did CalRecycle lower the plastic packaging baseline?

CalRecycle replaced its original modeled estimate with data submitted by participating producers. The updated figure is approximately 1.03 million tons, although it does not yet include complete and accurate information from all participating producers.

Does every producer have to reduce plastic packaging by 25%?

No. The 25% reduction target is a collective statewide requirement coordinated through the producer responsibility organization. Individual producers must meet their applicable obligations and contribute to the approved program.

When will California update its plastic packaging baseline?

CalRecycle plans to publish another correction in November 2027, incorporating additional and revised producer submissions before assessing compliance through the first annual reporting process in 2028.

Can companies face penalties for inaccurate reporting?

Yes. Companies that fail to meet applicable reporting requirements or continue submitting inaccurate information may face enforcement action or penalties. CalRecycle is currently working with producers to correct reporting deficiencies.

California Observer

Keeping a keen eye on the heartbeat of the Golden State.